Skip to main content

Nominal nonsense, the sequel

  • Author:
  • Updated:

Hey, remember back when we laughed at the lawsuit against Home Depot and Menard’s for fraudulently selling undersized 4x4’s? Well, I’ve got some half-good news.

A federal judge in Illinois – the home state of the law firm initiating the class action lawsuit – threw the case out against Menard’s for a number of stated reasons. None of those stated reasons included, surprisingly, “Geez, guys, just how stupid can you be?” Instead, Judge Edmond Chang cited that pretty much everyone who isn’t a complete knucklehead knows that 4x4s, 2x4s and other dimensional lumber doesn’t measure the actual nominal dimensions. Plus, the lumber is fully accessible in the store, allowing anyone to measure it before purchase.

And, in a victory of writers and editors everywhere, the judge also noted that there’s nothing dishonest about the names 2x4, 4x4 and others because those terms follow punctuation rules: There are no inch marks. That is, they’re not sold at 2"x4"s or 4"x4"s, meaning that the labels are, in his words, “literally true.”

As I said at the outset, this is only half-good news. Unfortunately, common sense has not yet ruled in the same lawsuit – initiated by the same law firm – currently pending against Home Depot. With luck, they’ll get the same judge.

Well, OK, sorry lawyers; I guess this one didn’t work so well for you. But, hey – Halloween is coming up. Have you considered a class action suite against Hershey, Mars and other candy companies regarding their “fun size” candy?

Sure, they’re enjoyable, but I suspect the “fun size” description is purely nominal.

Related Articles

Saved by the bell

Remember me telling you a local school is getting rid of their industrial arts programs, including woodshop? I have some good news.

Wood I, or wooden I

I’ve never stated before that there’s not a species of wood I won’t work with. Well, I take it back.

Sharing hopes

I’ve been making the most of self-isolation, and so far, so good.

Out of the ashes

Is the tide turning in the battle against the Emerald Ash Borer? Probably not yet, but there is a promising sign.

Temporary retirement

I’ve had a heavy workbench for at least 35 years, but I don’t use it much anymore. Time to let it enjoy a well-earned retirement?

Cheat sheets

Some things are so simple that they’re impossible – in my shop, anyway – to remember.

A stain on my record

I’ve long maintained that stain is a pain. I now realize that kind of thinking was, well, inane.


I’ve ruined a lot of projects by not leaving well enough alone, but sometimes tweaking really does improve something.